Some thoughts on the final debate of the 2020 presidential campaign.
On the format:
The mute button definitely worked. Kristen Welker did a solid job as moderator. Trump was under control. He started-out very mellow:
Symbolic gestures are important, especially in a pandemic:
This continues to be the essence of Trump’s approach to the coronavirus:
I have no idea what Trump meant when he criticized Biden for “selling pillows and sheets”:
Seth Cotlar gets it right:
When Trump attacked Biden’s family, Biden did not get into the mud. (There is a lot of material about the Trump family he could have used). Instead, he appealed to American families:
When Biden talked about American families and their “dinner table” concerns, Trump accused him of being a “typical politician.”:
Trump kept pushing lies about Biden’s positions on health care and fracking:
In one the better moments of the debate, Biden said that Trump was confused about the identity of his opponent in this election, especially as it relates to health care. Biden does not support socialized medicine. He actually won the Democratic primary against the likes of Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren who do favor socialized medicine. He reminded the viewers who Trump was running against:
The moderator, Kristen Welker, asked Trump about how his administration manage to lose the parents of 545 immigrant children. Trump claimed that they these children were brought to the country not by their parents, but by “coyotes.” Biden pushed back hard, saying that these children came to the United States with their parents and they were separated. Trump’s failed to exercise any degree of empathy for these children. It was painful to watch.
As a side note, I had interesting exchange on Twitter on this issue with court evangelical and GOP operative Ralph Reed:
I am not holding my breath about Reed’s decision to revisit this issue 10 days before an election.
Welker asked Biden and Trump about “the talk” African-American parents give their children about the dangers they will face in a racist society. Bruce Springsteen summarized this well in his song “American Skin”:
Here is the lyric:
41 shots, Lena gets her son ready for school
She says, “On these streets, Charles
You’ve got to understand the rules
If an officer stops you, promise me you’ll always be polite
And that you’ll never ever run away
Promise Mama you’ll keep your hands in sight”
Biden responded to this question with a clear statement about systemic racism, lamenting that such a “talk” is necessary in the United States of America. Trump never answered the question. Instead he said this:
Trump claimed he was the “least racist” person in the room. Then he backpedaled a bit, saying he couldn’t be entirely sure that he was the “least racist” person in the room because the lights were too bright and he was unable to see everyone.
Trump then went after Biden for his role in drafting the 1994 Crime Bill. This bill was controversial because it increased incarceration in an attempt to stop crime. It led to more prison sentences and aggressive policing that hurt people of color who are disproportionately likely to be incarcerated.
Biden has said that his support of the 1994 bill was a mistake and he regrets it. He said the same thing last night. But what confuses me is why Trump always criticizes him on this front. Wouldn’t a “law and order” president like Trump who does not believe in systemic racism be in favor of such a bill? After Trump’s response to racial unrest this summer, one might think he would have been chomping at the bit to support such a bill. Biden lost a chance to point this out.
New York Times columnist David Brooks weighed-in on the debate:
Biden said that he wanted to phase out the oil industry because it is bad for the environment. Trump implied that Biden’s statement alienated people in Texas, Pennsylvania, Oklahoma, and Ohio. Perhaps it did, but Biden stood his ground. Historian Andrew Wehrman put it succinctly:
Biden’s claim to be the president of all Americans reminded me of Thomas Jefferson’s first inaugural address:
Trump did fine. As CNN’s Dana Bash put it, the “bar was very low” for Trump and he managed to clear it.
Biden did fine as well. He had some nice moments.
I don’t think the debate changed much, especially since Trump is probably going to stay some more stupid stuff tomorrow and everyone will forget about last night’s debate.