During Q & A following the first plenary session of the State of the Evangelical Mind conference last week, I asked the audience: “What does it say about the state of the ‘evangelical mind’ if evangelicals cannot come up with enough money to support Books & Culture?”
Books & Culture was a Christian review of books edited by John Wilson and published by Christianity Today. As I noted in an earlier post, Mark Noll’s plenary address at the conference identified Books & Culture as one of the several signs of a thriving evangelical mind. Back in January, I wondered how evangelical intellectual life would continue to move forward after Books & Culture. My blog post called attention to Missouri State sociologist John Schmalzbauer’s piece at Comment magazine titled “The Life and Death of Evangelicalism’s Little Magazine.” Noll referenced both Schmalzbauer’s piece and my blog post in his address in Indianapolis.
John Wilson was honored during the conference for his work on Books & Culture. Indiana Wesleyan University, one of the conference sponsors, gave Wilson library bound copies of every issue of the periodical. It was a very meaningful gift, but someone is going to have to lug those books home! 🙂
Rachel Maxson, a librarian and instructor in the honors college at John Brown University, put the demise of Books & Culture in context. She began her talk by describing the conference as a “funeral”–a time to “grieve together” over the end of this important periodical. Maxson pointed to 2007 as the beginning of the end for print periodicals such as Books & Culture. In that year, Apple released the first iPhone, Amazon introduced the Kindle, the bottom of the housing market dropped out, and Harold Myra retired as the CEO of Christianity Today after thirty-two years at the organization. Traditional print publication took a serious hit from the iPhone and the Kindle. The tough economy made it difficult for periodicals such as Books & Culture to raise funds. And following Myra’s retirement, Christianity Today changed in a way that was not entirely clear from Maxson’s presentation.
After diagnosing what happened to Books & Culture, Maxson offered some general observations:
- It is too soon to say that “print is dead.” Maxson pointed to a survey that found that 92% of college students would rather have a print textbook.
- Evangelicals interested in promoting Christian thinking need to be more creative in their funding models.
- Evangelical public scholars and public intellectuals must be rewarded for their work when they “go up” for tenure and promotion.
- Evangelicals need to do a better job of creating “clearing houses” so that Christians know how to find good stuff on the Internet.
These are all excellent points that resonate with the work we do here at The Way of Improvement Leads Home. While we are a very small operation, we are slowly advancing our grassroots crowd-sourcing efforts to keep this little corner of Christian intellectual culture up and running. (Now might be a good time to think about investing in what we do here). In terms of tenure and promotion, I think Christian colleges have always been places where writing for the public has been rewarded. I also hope that The Way of Improvement Leads Home blog has been a clearing house to help you navigate the Web in a more thoughtful and responsible manner.
Stay tuned for most posts on the “State of the Evangelical Mind” conference.