I live in Barton country. When a Christian in this neck of the woods declares that another person only has “fire insurance” it’s a pretty serious putdown. Even people like Barton, who consider themselves to be expert authorities on everything, cannot unilaterally declare who is saved and who is not saved. People who do make such declarations would be subjecting themselves to public censure for claiming to know a person’s heart. So the next best thing you can do to putdown a person you believe is a “Christian In Name Only” (XINO) is to say they have “fire insurance” which generally means they responded to an altar call once and may have been baptized a long time ago but in no other visible way are they living out a Christian walk in their daily life.
Because he has not had success discrediting you as a historian he has decided to subtly attack your Christianity, using this Christianese code to indicate to his followers that you and your ilk (Warren Throckmorton, etc) are XINOs and should not be regarded as true Christian authorities. You are no better than those pagan professors at Harvard and Yale. Probably worse because you hide behind a cross. Therefore, his followers should disregard everything you say as though Saul Alinsky himself had said it.
I hope readers will remember that David Barton is not just a self-proclaimed historian, but he is also a Pentecostal Pastor who runs his own church in Aledo, TX. For a pastor to use words like this is extremely hurtful to the body and cause of Christ. He is deliberately trying to be insulting and divisive. It is anything but Christ-like. He should be ashamed to cast doubt on another person’s salvation while calling himself a shepherd. He doesn’t know anything about your walk with the Lord. Barton doesn’t just need to check his historical facts, he crossed a line with this statement and he needs to check his own heart as a pastor. He should apologize for that insulting statement or step down as a pastor. Shame on you Pastor David. You need to go back and read James 3:1.
Thanks for this Hannah. As I told Mark Kreslins yesterday when I appeared on his radio show, David Barton and other Christian nationalists have created an environment within the evangelical community where the depth or quality of a person’s faith is being judged by whether or not they believe America is a Christian nation.